Car insurances

Best Car Insurance Comparison

Brand

Top filters (10)

Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Price score

Features (6)

Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Cover for personal belongings
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Windscreen replacement
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
New car replacement timeframe
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Rental car after theft
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlimited rental car cover after not-at-fault accident
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Rental car after at-fault accident

Sort by

Filter by

Car insurance comparison

Last updated: 18 November 2025
Fact-checked
Fact-checked
Checked for accuracy by our qualified fact-checkers and verifiers. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE

Unlock our expert review and more

  • Reviews you can trust
  • Easy side-by-side comparison
  • Recommended products at a glance

Compare over 50 car insurers to find the best cover for your ride. Select cover that has your choice of repairer, rental car after an accident, or no excess cover for windscreen replacements from the biggest brands on the market – Allianz, Aldi, Australian Seniors, COTA, APIA, Everyday, NRMA, RACV, Coles, GIO, Youi and more.

Unlike other insurance comparison websites, we don’t get paid by any of the insurers we’re comparing. This means you sometimes won’t see price scores for insurers like NRMA and RACV, but it also means we don’t recommend insurers based on how much they pay comparison websites. We only recommend the best insurance policies for you.

Displaying all 69 products
Choose a field
Insurer (A-Z)
Member only access
CHOICE Expert Rating (High-Low)
Recommended (Z-A)
Price score (High-Low)
Sorry, no products meet the criteria for the filters you've applied.
TIO Comprehensive
74

TIO Comprehensive

Price score 85
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Hume Bank Comprehensive
72

Hume Bank Comprehensive

Price score 79
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
RAC Comprehensive
71

RAC Comprehensive

Price score 76
Customer satisfaction 77
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs No choice of repairer (but insurer will consider quotes you obtain). Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
GIO Comprehensive
71

GIO Comprehensive

Price score 71
Customer satisfaction 75
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Great Southern Bank Comprehensive
70

Great Southern Bank Comprehensive

Price score 74
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Kogan Comprehensive
70

Kogan Comprehensive

Price score 73
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Bank of Melbourne Comprehensive
69

Bank of Melbourne Comprehensive

Price score 72
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
BankSA Comprehensive
69

BankSA Comprehensive

Price score 72
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
NAB Comprehensive
69

NAB Comprehensive

Price score 70
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
St.George Comprehensive
69

St.George Comprehensive

Price score 72
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Westpac Comprehensive
69

Westpac Comprehensive

Price score 72
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
AAMI Comprehensive
69

AAMI Comprehensive

Price score 79
Customer satisfaction 62
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Apia Car Advantage
69

Apia Car Advantage

Price score 81
Customer satisfaction 68
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Covered for theft within 10 years of purchase, up to $40000
Join CHOICE
Suncorp Comprehensive
68

Suncorp Comprehensive

Price score 68
Customer satisfaction 68
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Suncorp Comprehensive Extras
67

Suncorp Comprehensive Extras

Price score 61
Customer satisfaction 68
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
RAA Standard Comprehensive
66

RAA Standard Comprehensive

Price score 55
Customer satisfaction 91
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while it is insured by you with RAA
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
National Seniors Comprehensive
65

National Seniors Comprehensive

Price score 62
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
QBE Comprehensive
63

QBE Comprehensive

Price score 48
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 3 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 60000km
Join CHOICE
RAA Premium Comprehensive
62

RAA Premium Comprehensive

Price score 40
Customer satisfaction 91
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while it is insured by you with RAA
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 5 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
RACT Comprehensive
62

RACT Comprehensive

Price score 70
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Real Insurance Comprehensive
61

Real Insurance Comprehensive

Price score 67
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE
Stella Comprehensive
60

Stella Comprehensive

Price score 45
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 3 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 60000km
Join CHOICE
Allianz Comprehensive
60

Allianz Comprehensive

Price score 52
Customer satisfaction 61
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Bingle Comprehensive
60

Bingle Comprehensive

Price score 72
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Market value only
New car replacement • Optional
• For total loss within 3 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
CBA Comprehensive
60

CBA Comprehensive

Price score 68
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE
BOQ Comprehensive
58

BOQ Comprehensive

Price score 54
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed as long as you or a family member own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
Everyday Insurance Comprehensive
58

Everyday Insurance Comprehensive

Price score 60
Customer satisfaction 71
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE
Aldi Comprehensive
58

Aldi Comprehensive

Price score 54
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed as long as you or a family member own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
RACQ Comprehensive
58

RACQ Comprehensive

Price score 49
Customer satisfaction 85
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed as long as you or a family member own the vehicle, but only for repairs done by insurer’s selected repairer
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE
GIO Platinum
57

GIO Platinum

Price score 35
Customer satisfaction 75
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Lifetime cover if you insured the vehicle with this policy within 13 months of purchase, and renewed continuously
Join CHOICE
Suncorp Comprehensive Advantages
54

Suncorp Comprehensive Advantages

Price score 28
Customer satisfaction 68
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Lifetime cover if you insured the vehicle with this policy within 13 months of purchase, and renewed continuously
Join CHOICE
AHM Comprehensive
51

AHM Comprehensive

Price score 50
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE
Huddle Comprehensive
50

Huddle Comprehensive

Price score 46
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE
Bupa Comprehensive
47

Bupa Comprehensive

Price score 39
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

AANT Comprehensive Plus

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 36 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

ANZ Comprehensive Plus

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 36 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

AANT Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

Bendigo Bank Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

NRMA Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 72
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

People First Bank Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

Over Fifty Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE

Beyond Bank Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE

Australian Unity Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE

HSBC Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE

COTA Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE

Coles Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 40000km
Join CHOICE

Budget Direct Gold Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 62
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 40000km
Join CHOICE

Budget Direct Gold Low Kilometres Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 62
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 40000km
Join CHOICE

ING Car Insurance

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 40000km
Join CHOICE

Qantas Car Insurance

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 70
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 40000km
Join CHOICE

Virgin Money Price Saver Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 40000km
Join CHOICE

Youi Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 77
Roadside assistance 1
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

Ozicare Car Insurance

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 1 year of purchase
• Must have fewer than 20000km
Join CHOICE

Bank Australia Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed as long as you or a family member own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 2 years of purchase
Join CHOICE

Bupa Ultimate Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 3 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 70000km
Join CHOICE

Huddle Black Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 3 years of purchase
• Must have fewer than 70000km
Join CHOICE

Australian Seniors Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Optional
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

ROLLiN' Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Market value only
New car replacement • Covered for total loss (no time limit)
• Must have fewer than 15000km
Join CHOICE

TrueCover Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance 1
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value only
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 12 months of purchase
• Must have fewer than 25000km
Join CHOICE

Bendigo Bank Comprehensive Plus

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 36 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

RACV Complete Care

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 64
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Your choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 36 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

RACV Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 64
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 24 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

NRMA Comprehensive Plus

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 72
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 36 months of purchase
Join CHOICE

PD Comprehensive

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed for lifetime of vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement • Covered for total loss within 12 months of purchase
• Must have fewer than 20000km
Join CHOICE

NRMA Comprehensive Basics

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction 72
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
Join CHOICE

People First Bank Comprehensive Basics

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
Join CHOICE

AANT Comprehensive Basics

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
Join CHOICE

Bendigo Bank Comprehensive Basics

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs No choice of repairer. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
Join CHOICE

People First Bank Comprehensive Plus

Price score N/A
Customer satisfaction N/A
Roadside assistance Sold separately
Repairs Choice of repairer is optional extra. Repairs guaranteed while you own the vehicle
How your car is valued Agreed value or market value
New car replacement Covered for total loss within 36 months of purchase
Join CHOICE