Sportswear, shoes and accessories
fitness tracker and smartwatch

Best Fitness Tracker And Smartwatch Reviews

Brand
Price

Top filters (4)

Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Join CHOICE
Type
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Join CHOICE
Shop Ethical rating

Test results (3)

Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Join CHOICE
Ease of use score
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Join CHOICE
Comfort score
Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Join CHOICE
Step count accuracy score

Features (4)

Specifications (3)

Related products (1)

Membership required
Unlock this by becoming a member
Join CHOICE
Availability

Sort by

Filter by

Fitness tracker and smartwatch reviews

Last updated: 18 November 2025
Fact-checked
Fact-checked
Checked for accuracy by our qualified fact-checkers and verifiers. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE

Unlock our expert review and more

  • Reviews you can trust
  • Easy side-by-side comparison
  • Recommended products at a glance
Join CHOICE
Denis Denis
James James

Fitness trackers and smartwatches make it possible to learn about your activity, sleep or eating habits by glancing at your smartphone or wrist.

Through our testing, we find out which trackers and smartwatches:

  • are the most accurate for fitness tracking
  • help you keep track of your steps, food intake and calories burned
  • are water-resistant and have GPS. 

We’ve also partnered with Shop Ethical on this update to show the ratings that the Ethical Consumer Group gives to each company.

Shopping links on the CHOICE website

CHOICE is an independent, nonprofit organisation dedicated to helping consumers. Clicking a link will take you to a retailer’s website to shop. While we make money if you buy through some retailer links, this doesn’t influence any of our rankings. 100% of the money we make goes straight back into our nonprofit mission. We’re currently testing this service and will consider providing more shopping links in the future. Tell us what you think.

View table View table
Displaying all 28 products
Choose a field
Price (Low-High)
Brand (A-Z)
Shop Ethical rating (Best-Worst)
Member only access
CHOICE Expert Rating (High-Low)
Ease of use score (High-Low)
Comfort score (High-Low)
Distance accuracy score (High-Low)
Step count accuracy score (High-Low)
Sorry, no products meet the criteria for the filters you've applied.
Garmin Vivosport
86
Discontinued

Garmin Vivosport

Ease of use score 77
Comfort score 85
Step count accuracy score 96
Shop Ethical rating F
$299
Join CHOICE
Garmin Vivofit 3
85
Discontinued

Garmin Vivofit 3

Ease of use score 82
Comfort score 74
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating F
$159
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Charge 3
85
Discontinued

Fitbit Charge 3

Ease of use score 85
Comfort score 74
Step count accuracy score 95
Shop Ethical rating F
$189
Join CHOICE
Garmin Vivofit 4
84
Recommended
Discontinued

Garmin Vivofit 4

Ease of use score 78
Comfort score 73
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating F
$139
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Versa
84
Discontinued

Fitbit Versa

Ease of use score 80
Comfort score 75
Step count accuracy score 95
Shop Ethical rating F
$249
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Inspire HR
84
Discontinued

Fitbit Inspire HR

Ease of use score 74
Comfort score 78
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating F
$179
Join CHOICE
Garmin Vivoactive
84
Discontinued

Garmin Vivoactive

Ease of use score 82
Comfort score 74
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating F
$299
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Surge
83
Discontinued

Fitbit Surge

Ease of use score 83
Comfort score 68
Step count accuracy score 97
Shop Ethical rating F
$400
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Versa 4
82
Recommended

Fitbit Versa 4

Ease of use score 83
Comfort score 65
Step count accuracy score 96
Shop Ethical rating F
$380
Join CHOICE
TomTom Spark
82
Discontinued

TomTom Spark

Ease of use score 85
Comfort score 64
Step count accuracy score 97
Shop Ethical rating D
$224
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Ionic
82
Discontinued

Fitbit Ionic

Ease of use score 87
Comfort score 63
Step count accuracy score 96
Shop Ethical rating F
$399
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Blaze
82
Discontinued

Fitbit Blaze

Ease of use score 78
Comfort score 69
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating F
$279
Join CHOICE
TomTom Adventurer
81
Discontinued

TomTom Adventurer

Ease of use score 79
Comfort score 66
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating D
$449
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Charge HR
81
Discontinued

Fitbit Charge HR

Ease of use score 74
Comfort score 71
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating F
$230
Join CHOICE
Huawei Watch 2
81
Discontinued

Huawei Watch 2

Ease of use score 68
Comfort score 77
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating D
$599
Join CHOICE
Garmin Vivosmart 4
81
Recommended
Discontinued

Garmin Vivosmart 4

Ease of use score 74
Comfort score 73
Step count accuracy score 100
Shop Ethical rating F
$199
Join CHOICE
Garmin Venu
80
Discontinued

Garmin Venu

Ease of use score 77
Comfort score 68
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating F
$499
Join CHOICE
Samsung Gear Fit2
80
Discontinued

Samsung Gear Fit2

Ease of use score 75
Comfort score 70
Step count accuracy score 97
Shop Ethical rating F
$289
Join CHOICE
Amazfit GTR 4
80

Amazfit GTR 4

Ease of use score 78
Comfort score 64
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$299
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Alta HR
80
Discontinued

Fitbit Alta HR

Ease of use score 80
Comfort score 63
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating F
$79
Join CHOICE
Polar A370
79
Discontinued

Polar A370

Ease of use score 71
Comfort score 71
Step count accuracy score 96
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$299
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Charge 2
79
Discontinued

Fitbit Charge 2

Ease of use score 79
Comfort score 66
Step count accuracy score 87
Shop Ethical rating F
$199
Join CHOICE
TomTom Touch
79
Discontinued

TomTom Touch

Ease of use score 62
Comfort score 75
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating D
$210
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Alta
78
Discontinued

Fitbit Alta

Ease of use score 74
Comfort score 62
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating F
$159
Join CHOICE
Samsung Gear S2
78
Discontinued

Samsung Gear S2

Ease of use score 67
Comfort score 71
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating F
$499
Join CHOICE
Misfit Shine
77
Discontinued

Misfit Shine

Ease of use score 69
Comfort score 76
Step count accuracy score 91
Shop Ethical rating D
$86
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Flex 2
77
Discontinued

Fitbit Flex 2

Ease of use score 68
Comfort score 68
Step count accuracy score 96
Shop Ethical rating F
$150
Join CHOICE
Motorola Moto 360
76
Discontinued

Motorola Moto 360

Ease of use score 56
Comfort score 73
Step count accuracy score 95
Shop Ethical rating C
$440
Join CHOICE
Microsoft Band 2
76
Discontinued

Microsoft Band 2

Ease of use score 70
Comfort score 60
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating C
$379
Join CHOICE
Xiaomi MI Band 2
76
Discontinued

Xiaomi MI Band 2

Ease of use score 67
Comfort score 61
Step count accuracy score 100
Shop Ethical rating F
$71
Join CHOICE
Polar A360
76
Discontinued

Polar A360

Ease of use score 69
Comfort score 63
Step count accuracy score 97
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$298
Join CHOICE
Fitbit Ace
75
Discontinued

Fitbit Ace

Ease of use score 71
Comfort score 69
Step count accuracy score 93
Shop Ethical rating F
$99
Join CHOICE
Misfit Vapor
75
Discontinued

Misfit Vapor

Ease of use score 70
Comfort score 66
Step count accuracy score 94
Shop Ethical rating D
$199
Join CHOICE
iFit Vue
75
Discontinued

iFit Vue

Ease of use score 59
Comfort score 68
Step count accuracy score 97
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$99
Join CHOICE
Polar M200
75
Discontinued

Polar M200

Ease of use score 69
Comfort score 61
Step count accuracy score 95
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$249
Join CHOICE
Polar M600
74
Discontinued

Polar M600

Ease of use score 66
Comfort score 60
Step count accuracy score 96
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$350
Join CHOICE
Jawbone Up2
74
Discontinued

Jawbone Up2

Ease of use score 60
Comfort score 68
Step count accuracy score 94
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$71
Join CHOICE
Misfit Shine 2
74
Discontinued

Misfit Shine 2

Ease of use score 62
Comfort score 75
Step count accuracy score 90
Shop Ethical rating D
$140
Join CHOICE
iFit Duo Knight
73
Discontinued

iFit Duo Knight

Ease of use score 68
Comfort score 56
Step count accuracy score 95
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$299
Join CHOICE
Sony Smartband 2
73
Discontinued

Sony Smartband 2

Ease of use score 58
Comfort score 62
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating C
$199
Join CHOICE
iFit Axis HR
72
Discontinued

iFit Axis HR

Ease of use score 55
Comfort score 64
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$199
Join CHOICE
Jawbone UP Move
72
Discontinued

Jawbone UP Move

Ease of use score 60
Comfort score 56
Step count accuracy score 99
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$86
Join CHOICE
Misfit Command
69
Discontinued

Misfit Command

Ease of use score 61
Comfort score 58
Step count accuracy score 90
Shop Ethical rating D
$199
Join CHOICE
Jawbone Up 3
69
Discontinued

Jawbone Up 3

Ease of use score 60
Comfort score 49
Step count accuracy score 98
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$246
Join CHOICE
Mio Alpha 2
69
Discontinued

Mio Alpha 2

Ease of use score 58
Comfort score 72
Step count accuracy score 93
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$299
Join CHOICE
Polar Loop 2
64
Discontinued

Polar Loop 2

Ease of use score 65
Comfort score 57
Step count accuracy score 95
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$108
Join CHOICE
Misfit Ray
61
Discontinued

Misfit Ray

Ease of use score 55
Comfort score 56
Step count accuracy score 80
Shop Ethical rating D
$139
Join CHOICE
Nixon The Mission
58
Discontinued

Nixon The Mission

Ease of use score 42
Comfort score 43
Step count accuracy score 91
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$399
Join CHOICE
Wisewear Calder
53
Discontinued

Wisewear Calder

Ease of use score 39
Comfort score 27
Step count accuracy score 92
Shop Ethical rating N/A
$99
Join CHOICE
Denis

Denis Gallagher is a Senior project officer for Digital home products and also works on test projects for the laundry and fridge labs. He produces tests for gadgets, phones, cameras and home entertainment gear as well as TVs, washing machines, dishwashers and fridges.  Previously at CHOICE, Denis worked as a Content producer for digital products. Prior to CHOICE, Denis worked as an Assistant editor on Golf Australia magazine and Editor for Multimedia and Videocamera magazine.  Denis has a Bachelor of Arts from the University of New South Wales and a Diploma of Journalism from Macleay College. Find Denis on LinkedIn.

Denis Gallagher is a Senior project officer for Digital home products and also works on test projects for the laundry and fridge labs. He produces tests for gadgets, phones, cameras and home entertainment gear as well as TVs, washing machines, dishwashers and fridges.  Previously at CHOICE, Denis worked as a Content producer for digital products. Prior to CHOICE, Denis worked as an Assistant editor on Golf Australia magazine and Editor for Multimedia and Videocamera magazine.  Denis has a Bachelor of Arts from the University of New South Wales and a Diploma of Journalism from Macleay College. Find Denis on LinkedIn.

James

James Thomson tests TVs, speakers, fitness bands and other household digital gadgets in the digital home team at CHOICE. He also tests outdoor products like pressure cleaners, line trimmers and pool cleaners. James has a Bachelor of Science from the University of Sydney, where he majored in computer science. Prior to CHOICE, James worked as a programmer and analyst at an insurance company for 20 years. James represents consumers on the Australian Standards committee for TE-021 – Energy performance for Audio/Video, Information and Communication Technology and Associated Equipment.

James Thomson tests TVs, speakers, fitness bands and other household digital gadgets in the digital home team at CHOICE. He also tests outdoor products like pressure cleaners, line trimmers and pool cleaners. James has a Bachelor of Science from the University of Sydney, where he majored in computer science. Prior to CHOICE, James worked as a programmer and analyst at an insurance company for 20 years. James represents consumers on the Australian Standards committee for TE-021 – Energy performance for Audio/Video, Information and Communication Technology and Associated Equipment.