Life insurers AMP and Asteron dragging their feet on claims

Insurer AMP is taking much longer than its competitors to assess death claims, according to 2018 data collected by industry regulators APRA and ASIC. 

Almost one in five (18.5%) claims were left in limbo for more than a year, compared with the industry average of just over a month.

The company has been under siege since some of its practices, including charging fees for no service, were heavily criticised during the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry. 

Asteron, which provides insurance for Suncorp Super, also stood out for all the wrong reasons. It recorded a dispute ratio – the number of disputes against claims per people insured – that was 12 times higher than the industry mean for total and permanent disability (TPD) claims.

Asteron had the highest dispute rate for TPD claims 

In TPD disputes, Asteron had the highest dispute ratio, with 181.5 disputes per 100,000 people insured, compared with an industry average of 14.5.

An Asteron spokesperson told Super Consumers Australia at CHOICE that the dispute lodgement figures partly reflected ‘legacy’ policies. These are policies that are ‘closed’ or no longer available to customers.

 “A significant proportion of Asteron’s Group TPD claims are late-reported claims from an old legacy book,” the spokesperson says. “This adds to the complexity of the claims assessment process due to the difficulty in obtaining historical evidence to establish claims-acceptance criteria.” 

“We have a number of initiatives underway to limit disputes and ensure the best possible outcome for our customers.”

What is the goal of publishing this data? 

Collecting and publishing this information has taken a long time. APRA and ASIC describe it as a “world-leading” project.

The hope was to allow people to assess the quality of their insurance by looking at how long the insurers take to process claims, how often they deny them, and how often disputes arise.

But many of the insurers are merely wholesalers, providing insurance for multiple super funds. This means each product may offer different levels of cover, making it hard for consumers to compare them. 

“While interesting, this information is not even close to useful for most people,” says Xavier O’Halloran, director of Super Consumers Australia. “Many would struggle to name their superannuation fund, let alone the insurer sitting behind it.”

“To fix this, market regulators must go much further and release product level comparisons. Without this, people are in the dark about the quality of their insurance in super.” 

Super Consumers Australia has asked ASIC and APRA for comment.

---

Daniel

I'm an investigative journalist at Super Consumers Australia, a partnership with CHOICE, which gives consumers a voice in an industry that has long been dominated by powerful lobby groups. I've reported on the impact of underperforming super funds, the experiences of those claiming on superannuation insurance and the fast-growing field of ethical super. I enjoy the opportunity to do long-form journalism, digging deep into an industry that impacts almost every Australian. Previously, I've written for The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Australian, The Guardian and The Saturday Paper. I also had my first novel published by Harper Collins and have worked as an intellectual property lawyer and public servant. You can find me on Twitter and LinkedIn.

I'm an investigative journalist at Super Consumers Australia, a partnership with CHOICE, which gives consumers a voice in an industry that has long been dominated by powerful lobby groups. I've reported on the impact of underperforming super funds, the experiences of those claiming on superannuation insurance and the fast-growing field of ethical super. I enjoy the opportunity to do long-form journalism, digging deep into an industry that impacts almost every Australian. Previously, I've written for The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Australian, The Guardian and The Saturday Paper. I also had my first novel published by Harper Collins and have worked as an intellectual property lawyer and public servant. You can find me on Twitter and LinkedIn.

Related

Life insurance can help you financially if you're sick or injured, but what does it cover and do you really need it?

A guide to insurance in superannuation

How much you need to maintain your standard of living, based on actual spending by retirees.

Retirement savings targets: How much do you need to retire?

Companies are charging big fees to help desperate consumers get early access to super.

Dentists and the superannuation rort

What is super, when are you entitled to it, when can you access it and how do you find the best super fund?

A beginner’s guide to superannuation: What you need to know