Loans are being approved without proper checks and used cars are breaking down soon after purchase.
Proposed buy now, pay later reforms a partial solution
A coalition of advocates say draft legislation should do more to protect consumers.
Fact-checked
Fact-checked
Checked for accuracy by our qualified fact-checkers and verifiers. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE
The government’s draft legislation on regulating buy now, pay later (BNPL) products under the Credit Act is a welcome development, but concerns remain, according to consumer groups.
CHOICE, along with 10 other consumer and financial groups such as Financial Counselling Australia, Indigenous Consumer Assistance Network and Consumer Action Law Centre, has responded to the government’s consultations on draft legislation with a submission urging the government to finalise reforms “as a matter of priority” this year.
If BNPL is going to be sold with only partial safe lending laws applying, the laws need to do more to ensure BNPL products are actually safer
CHOICE and other advocates in a submission to government
“We are not convinced that the intention of proportionate regulation that introduces meaningful safeguards has been achieved. To remedy this, the [draft] must be amended so that BNPL products present less risk for consumers,” the submission reads.
“If BNPL is going to be sold with only partial safe lending laws applying, the laws need to do more to ensure BNPL products are actually safer,” it says.
Improvements
In announcing the draft legislation in March this year, Financial Services Minister Stephen Jones said BNPL services would be required to take steps to make sure they are lending responsibly.
“This requirement will operate in a way that is flexible, adaptable and proportionate to the risk of consumer harm,” he said.
CHOICE’s head of policy Tom Abourizk says the reforms would require BNPL providers to be members of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority so that consumers have access to dispute resolution.
“Passing the draft legislation would dramatically improve the consumer protections that currently apply to BNPL,” he says.
More should be done to genuinely ensure BNPL is a lower risk product
CHOICE head of policy Tom Abourizk
But there are other areas where the reforms fall short.
“More should be done to genuinely ensure BNPL is a lower risk product if safe lending assessments that apply to other credit products are not required. This could be done by limiting the maximum value of BNPL loans or prohibiting actions such as securing BNPL debts over property or initiating bankruptcy proceedings over BNPL debts,” he says.
Abourizk adds that the current legislation draft prioritises speed of lending approvals for the industry, rather than accuracy.
“The laws will help many consumers, but some people will still be sold BNPL that will leave them worse off, and they won’t have any right to recourse,” he adds.
Read the full submission and recommendations.
Related
The corporate regulator says it's working to stop Cigno Australia's predatory lending models for good.
Consumer protections that apply to credit products will now apply to BNPL providers such as Afterpay, Zip and Humm.
Consumer advocates say an inquiry into the industry is long overdue.